Posts Tagged ‘ Banana Chiquita ’

Just for Kids: How Bananas Came to America

By

This is a special post, excerpted and modified from my book, designed for kids, visiting from The Mini Page, a syndicated feature published in over 500 newspapers every week.

Lorenzo Dow Baker: Banana Pioneer

Bananas were available in the United States immediately following the Civil War. But they were a luxury item, like caviar, consumed more for status than taste. (Plantains, for cooking, had been a staple in the southern parts of the hemisphere since Spanish times.)  Most Americans had never seen, sampled, or even heard of the fruit. What few bananas North Americans ate were sold at a dime apiece—about two dollars today—and came peeled, sliced, and wrapped in foil. They were usually mushy and brown by the time they got to the table.

The closest place to the U.S. bananas could be grown, at the time, was Jamaica. The trip from that Caribbean island to the ports of the American northeast could take as long as three weeks aboard the sail-driven schooners of the day. That wasn’t fast enough to keep bananas fresh. But if the winds were just right, a ship could sail faster. Then, a cargo hold full of bananas could fetch a fine price.

In 1870, a Cape Cod sea captain named Lorenzo Dow Baker brought 160 bunches of bananas from Jamaica to the docks at Jersey City, New Jersey. That voyage launched the banana industry in the United States.

Baker’s banana career happened almost by chance, as a byproduct of one of the era’s most daring seafaring adventures. After setting out from Cape Cod, he sailed his ship—the Telegraph—across the Caribbean, to the mouth of Venezuela’s Orinoco River. His passengers were ten gold miners, all anxious to search for riches in excavations they’d heard about 300 miles upstream. The journey upriver- through mosquito-infested jungle, deep into unknown territory – took three months. Baker dropped off the prospectors, collected his pay—$8,500 in gold, or about $125,000 today—and turned toward home.

The trip had almost wrecked the Telegraph, and the old sea captain was forced to stop at Jamaica for repairs. Once they were completed, he prepared to head north to the States. Just before he did, he spotted some bananas on the dock, and decided, at the last minute, to buy them and bring them along. Baker believed he could make it back to the mainland in two weeks. He’d keep the bananas on deck, in order to expose them to cool air, and if the wind and weather were right, he could make back some of the money he’d spent refurbishing his beaten-up ship. The plan worked. Baker got home in eleven days, arriving with bananas fresh enough to wholesale at two dollars a bunch. His profit on the shipment was the equivalent of $6,400 today.

Within a year, Baker was the biggest banana exporter in the Caribbean, becoming so enthusiastic about the new business that he bought land at Port Antonio, Jamaica, where he planted acres of fruit and built a sprawling estate. Baker’s business expanded, and soon, other American entrepreneurs arrived, along with young men recruited – salaries were high -  to run the plantations. These first American banana executives built their own elaborate homes, hired servants, and became famous for lighting their cigars with five dollar bills.  For native Jamaicans, banana picking was brutal, dangerous work. They were paid for their labor, but the money didn’t last: even if they didn’t choose to spend their money in the town’s bars, saloons, and gambling halls, they’d still have to pay high, fixed prices for their basic needs. In the end, where their wages actually went didn’t matter: Port Antonio’s enterprises – licit and illicit – were banana-company owned.

Another beneficiary of Baker’s business was Andrew Preston, a 25-year old New England produce buyer who couldn’t keep enough of the tropical fruit in stock. For over a decade, Preston had worked at a Boston grocery wholesaler, slowly advancing from janitor to bookkeeper to in-the-field representative. His job was to meet ships at the docks and bargain for whatever fruits and vegetables they were unloading. When he first set eyes the Jamaican bananas, he knew he was looking at something important: “I saw ‘em, I bought ‘em, and I sold ‘em,” he later said.

Baker and Preston became partners in 1885. The two men couldn’t have been more different. Baker was a weathered, broad-chested, rough-hewn seafarer, with a bushy black beard framed by wild sideburns. Preston wanted to accepted by wealthy society; though he wasn’t well-educated, he acted as if he were. While he lacked Baker’s ruggedness and experience with conditions in the wild, he made up for it with a belief in bananas so strong that he was able to attract investors willing to risk their own money in an enterprise whose purpose was to sell a product Americans still knew almost nothing about. The Bostonian raised $16,000 from eight backers, forming the world’s first commercial banana company.  “Boston Fruit” was the inaugural name – one of four -  the business would adopt. Today, it is known as Chiquita.

The partners were very ambitious. Andrew Preston didn’t just want every American to pick up a few bananas now and then. He wanted the fruit, he told his fellow entrepreneurs, to be “more popular than apples.” But apples could be delivered to grocers within a day or two of harvest. Even after the banana industry abandoned sailing ships for steam-powered vessels—cutting the journey from the Caribbean to less than five days—the trip north was risky. Entire loads sometimes arrived overripe and rotting.  The answer was chilled air. Cold keeps bananas green, allowing them to travel further distances. Baker had already set up a system of cold-storage rooms throughout the United States, connected to a network of shipping facilities and railroad hubs. The warehouses weren’t refrigerated – that technology was still decades away. Instead, they used plain old ice, which was literally brought south in huge chunks every winter, floated on rivers and stored in massive, insulated warehouses (ice, in the days before refrigeration, was one of the most profitable businesses in the industrialized world.)

But Preston’s banana network, formidable as it was, was useless if the fruit arrived already spoiled. The boats, he realized, needed to be cooled, as well.

This was something nobody had attempted. It wasn’t just the task of building insulated ships, or figuring out how to invent cargo holds that would accommodate the ice and circulate the air properly. These ships had to do all that, and do it for voyages to the hottest places in the hemisphere.

The ships Preston built were technological marvels. The holds for the ice were segregated from the holds for the bananas, so that once the ice was put in them, they could be sealed off. No hot air could enter them. Instead, the cold air was channeled through the ship through an elaborate venting system. The ships were remarkably energy efficient, as well. They were painted pure white, so that they’d absorb as little heat as possible; they were shaped for speed, so that time in transit would be cut to a minimum. Preston’s engineers even invented radio systems that would allow ship operators to communicate with plantation managers on shore, so that harvested bunches could be ready and waiting as soon as the banana boats arrived at port. Every second counted.

There was another innovation, as well: the system wasn’t just good at cooling bananas. It also worked to keep people comfortable. The company’s banana armada, which soon became known as “The Great White Fleet,” was designed to be convertible. On trips south, the vessels operated as luxury cruise liners. The ventilation ducts that channelled air toward the fruit would be reconfigured to move it into passenger cabins. All of this innovation went toward a single goal: squeeze every penny possible from every possible place, so that bananas could remain cheap. That was the key to Preston’s strategy.

What Preston and Baker accomplished with their bananas should have been impossible. Think about how quickly bananas turn brown or bruise. They overcame that difficulty to bring consumers a fragile,tropical product intact and ready to eat, thousands of miles from the place it grew, at a price everyone could afford! They did it by developing a formula the banana conglomerates still employ today: work on a large scale, control transportation and distribution, and aggressively dominate land and labor. Keep costs low in every possible way. They did it in ways that were often brilliant, but also in ways that were not always fair, or decent, or moral. Over the next century, much blood would be spilled in the name of cheap bananas. But the result was that the banana cost half as much as apples, and Americans couldn’t get enough of the new fruit.

The world’s favorite fruit finally became our favorite, as well.


Chiquita connection to Honduras crisis?

By

The Democracy Now radio program interviewed Nicholas Kozloff, who argued that there’s a Chiquita connection in the current Honduran political crisis, which saw President Manuel Zelaya deposed in either a coup or a constitutional emergency, or both, depending on which side you’re on, in June. The banana industry once made Honduras its largest exporting nation; that changed with Hurricane Mitch, in 1986, which devastated the crop, but there’s still a huge plantation network there. Here’s what Kozloff had to say:

“…there’s this revolving door of Washington insiders that are supporting companies like Chiquita banana. I just wrote an article about Chiquita, formerly known as the United Fruit Company. And, you know, throughout history, Chiquita banana has had enormous sway and power over Central American nations.

And we know that prior to the coup d’état in Honduras, Chiquita was very unhappy about President Zelaya’s minimum wage decrees, because they said that this would cut into their profits and make it more expensive for them to export bananas and pineapple. And we know that they appealed to the Honduran Business Association, which was also opposed to Zelaya’s minimum wage provisions.

And we also—and what I find really interesting is that Chiquita is allied to a Washington law firm called Covington, which advises multinational corporations. And who is the vice chairman of Covington? None other than John Negroponte, who your previous guest mentioned in regards to the rampant human rights abuses that went on in Honduras throughout the 1980s. So I think that’s a really interesting connection.”

via “From Arbenz to Zelaya: Chiquita in Latin America”. (Here’s a link to Kozloff’s article that the interview was based on.)

As I’ve pointed out earlier, assertions like this have fundamental credibility, because the banana industry’s business model absolutely mandates cheaply-produced product. Chiquita and Dole would collapse if they couldn’t sell this perishable fruit, transported from thousands of miles away, for less than any other fruit – even locally grown apples – in the supermarket. That’s why Dole sues filmmakers whose work might rally support for lawsuits brought by injured workers; and why the banana industry has been involved – time and again – in coups, bribery, payoffs, and general skullduggery (tons documented in my book and this site. Here’s a link to one of the more recent incidents.

“60 Minutes” updates Chiquita report

By
CBS’s “60 Minutes” reran its May, 2008 segment, called “The Price of Bananas,” on Chiquita’s payments to a Colombian paramilitaries. New information included the extradition of a member of that group to the U.S., confirmation by additional sources, and the expansion of an investigation of similar alleged payments made by Dole.


Watch the report. Read a transcript.


Related posts:

  • Last year’s entry is here.
  • Chiquita’s lawyer is Eric Holder, now U.S. attorney general. Here’s my March, 2008 entry.
  • 400 Colombian families are suing the banana giant. My November, 2007 entry is here.

Tweeting Banana Arrivals in San Diego

By

Banana Boat

From Danforth’s flickr stream.

Writer/comedian Danforth France saw this Dole freighter unloading in San Diego while he was attending last week’s Comic-Con, and he sent me the linked tweet.

The ship is the Dole Honduras – one of two that constitute the banana giant’s Pacific fleet. The vessel makes over 20 annual north-south trips along a route that stretches from San Diego to Puerto Quetzal, Guatemala; Caldera, Costa Rica; Guayaquil, Ecuador; and Paita, Peru, according to  Dole Ocean Cargo.

Danforth’s image was taken July 26, and the vessel’s current schedule indicates that it is handling shorter haul work right now. The Port of San Diego’s Marine Information System indicates that it has already made a full round trip since then, and is due back today. It will depart for Costa Rica on Tuesday, August 4,

The most interesting thing about the vessel is its color. Tradition has it that banana boats be painted white. Chiquita’s ships, starting even before the early 1900s,were known as the “Great White Fleet.” Though the Honduras is a bit of a shabby beige, it fits the traditional scheme, which is more than just  custom. Bananas are highly perishable and grown far away. They have to be shipped under refrigeration if they’re to arrive at your supermarket  ready-to-ripen, rather than icky brown. But despite these formidable built-in costs, bananas remain incredibly cheap. That seemingly impossible paradox can only be overcome  if  every cost-cutting measure is taken –  so heat-reflecting paint jobs have been part the fruit’s business model almost since day one.

Thanks, Danforth!

Seen any interesting banana stuff lately? Tweet me….

A Guide to Those "Baby" Bananas – and What They Prove

By

on_bananacostume_baby.jpg

Huggable, lovable – but not the kind of baby banana that I’m talking about.

Though the vast majority of bananas we buy – statistically, all – are of the endangered Cavendish variety, there’s a good chance you’ve seen something else, these days and if you’re a banana-type (or have become one), you might have wondered: what are those little bananas?

Both Chiquita and Dole offer versions of the half-sized fruit, with Chiquita selling them under the “Minis” brand, and Dole offering them as “Baby” bananas.

In the “big” banana world, there’s absolutely no difference between what Chiquita, Dole (or any other commercial banana importer) sells: everything is Cavendish. Action surrounds small-time fruit. For the first time in over a century, the two biggest banana companies are slugging it out for a market niche with different varieties.

The Chiquita “Mini” is a breed called Pisang Mas, originally from Malaysia, but now – like all bananas imported to the U.S. – grown in Latin America.

Dole actually sells three different varieties under the Baby band nameOrito, Lady Finger, and Manzano.

The fruit are tough to find, since they’re in various stages of test-marketing, as well as subject to seasonal variation. They also cost about three times as much as their ordinary counterparts. But they’re worth seeking out, and not just because they prove – possibly for the first time to the average American consumer – that there’s something beyond the generic banana. Though the four types share some characteristics (beyond size), they’re also quite different from each other.

I’ve put together a guide to the four varieties, but one caveat: no great banana arrives easily. Dole doesn’t distinguish between the three types it offers – they’re all labelled the same – so side-by-side taste tests are going to be tough. But persevere. The results will be worth it (and ignore the for-kids marketing that the banana giants have attached to the product. Sure, they are great after school, as Chiquita’s says. But this isn’t baby food.)

Oh, and one more thing, and you MUST do this, or else your adventure in little bananas will surely fail: LITTLE BANANAS TASTE HORRIBLE UNTIL THEY’RE RIPE – AND RIPE, FOR LITTLE BANANAS, IS NOT YELLOW! You need to let the fruit turn brown or else it will not be sweet or soft enough. This will go against every banana extinct you have been trained to adhere to. Trust me.


CHIQUITA’S PISANG MAS (BRAND NAME: MINI)

NEW MINIS CLUSTERsm



  • Super sweet – but only when very ripe. This is a fruit that is awesome when “peaking,” but the peak can be hard to catch. When not peaking, not so good.
  • Thin-skinned, so it bruises easily.
  • IDENTIFYING: Easy. The only one Chiquita sells.

DOLE’S BABY (TYPE II – ORITO):

Orito

Orito Banana, from Ecuador’s Goldenforce.

  • Possibly the sweetest of the four varieties – making it (when ripe – see above) one of the best bananas for smoothies.
  • Grown almost exclusively in Ecuador, where labor laws are weak, making this a very high-margin, high-political cost fruit.
  • Identification: Chubby. If the country of origin is Ecuador, almost definitely Orito.

DOLE BABY (TYPE II – LADY FINGER):

ladyfinger

Ladyfinger, meet Cavendish. Photo: Australian Tropical Fruits Portal


  • Similar peaking/ripening characteristics as Pisang Mas.
  • Doesn’t easily turn brown when cut, making it perfect for fruit salads.
  • Susceptible to Panama Disease Race One, the malady that killed the first worldwide commercial banana crop – and which still exists today.
  • Closer to a mini-Cavendish in appearance. Slender(ish.) Super popular in Australia, so if you’ve got an Aussie in tow ask him or her for identification help.

DOLE BABY (TYPE III – MANZANO/APPLE):

MANAZANO

The chubby Manzano, or “apple” banana. Photo: Thrifty Foods

  • Falls into the “apple” banana category – giving it a unique, tangy-sweet taste. Much less bland than our Cavendish, but some banana marketers have traditionally believed that consumers would reject such a different-flavored fruit.
  • Definitely the most “gourmet” banana of the bunch.
  • Small ripeness/sweetness issue. Can be eaten a little bit less brown if you like the tart flavor, but you must wait beyond brown – until the skin is black – for the highest sugar content (which will give you a fabulous, multi-dimensional bite.)
  • Difficult to grow in wet, lowland conditions
  • Easier to find than others – sold under many brand names (or none at all) in Latin markets, where it is often a Mexican import.
  • Identification tips: Significantly fatter, chunkier than Cavendish and probably the other little bananas, as well.

Once you’ve tried a couple, it’s worth thinking a bit about what this all means in a world where the single fruit that we generally eat is threatened with practical extinction. The arrival of these alternate bananas in our markets shows that variety is possible, and that the commercial banana companies are willing to experiment with it (even with the for-kids-only marketing tilt.)

Despite this, the banana companies are likely very hesitant to move the fruit into any testing beyond these niches. The reason is that – according to conventional industry wisdom – there’s simply too much “wrong” with the pint-sized fruit. The main arguments against mainstreaming mini-bananas include:

  • Ripening. All of these fruit must be quite dark to taste good. The banana companies are (rightly?) afraid that the typical consumer is so well conditioned toward seeing a golden banana as perfect that wider acceptance would simply never occur.
  • Production. The varieties in question can’t be grown as broadly, geographically speaking, as Cavendish. There probably isn’t enough land in Latin America to make any one of these varieties anything near to a market share winner.
  • Shipping: These are thin-skinned fruit. Today’s banana supply chain is so industrialized that the little fruit don’t fit into it, requiring costly “custom” handling all along the way. For an industry built on turning an exotic tropical fruit into a commodity as cheap and ubiquitous as a fast-food burger, the idea of reinventing itself to handle more complex products may feel both financially and culturally risky.
  • Marketing. People buy bananas by the bunch. Would the price/weight equation shift with a smaller banana as our main choice, or even as a more prominent alternate? The banana has been America’s favorite fruit – by far – since the 1920s. Changing the very size, shape, and price of that fruit into something completely new would be a terrifying prospect for the banana companies, which introduced the fruit to us, struggled to make it our favorite, and have fought – often spilling blood – to keep it exactly the same ever since.

Despite all this, change has to come.

All of these arguments are based on a single premise: that the banana we eat today will last forever. It won’t. It might not even last a decade.

The truth is that, as a living organism, all bananas have strengths, and all bananas have weaknesses. The biggest weakness the world’s banana crop has today, though, has nothing to do with the fruit itself: it has to do with the human folly of relying on a single variety to feed millions.

The half-sized varieties from Chiquita and Dole are not, I’m told, doing all that well at the market. Some of Dole’s farms in Ecuador that were devoted to the Orito fruit are reported to have closed. But the proof of concept – getting the fruit from there to here, figuring out how to market and sell it - has been accomplished, and despite my frequent criticism of the banana companies, there’s credit deserved for that.

The experiment, however, needs to be seen as more than just marketing. The biological common sense – and necessity – of breaking the Cavendish monoculture needs to be acknowledged, as well. It is in combining salesmanship with this common sense that will lead the industry away from the dead end it is now rapidly heading toward. The “Mini” and “Baby” fruit provide a blueprint – even, focused as it is on children, it appears to have been written in crayon.

Banana Price Watch: 7-Eleven, Los Angeles

By


That’s my beloved local Sev. To zoom in, you’ve got to go there. So go.

Interesting strategy at my favorite local convenience store, on the corner of Sunset Blvd. and Rosemont In the Silverlake neighborhood of Los Angeles (just steps from Dodger Stadium.)

Instead of the typical branded, presented-in-a-box fruit Chiquita is selling in many U.S. convenience stores, the fruit here is bought at local supermarkets and sold in an ordinary basket. At the current price – 69 cents per banana – the store manager told me customers purchased a respectable fifty or so a day. Still, he thought he could do better, and was about to add a twofer, with a pair of bananas going for a buck. 

The DIY approach nets the local shop a considerable profit over Chiquita's all-in-one strategy, which involves a national distribution network of refrigerated product, each fruit with a sticker on it, to of about 13,000 convenience stores. Chiquita's suggested retail price for its product is 75 to 99 cents. The benefit, it says, is that that the controlled supplyand special packaging allows the fruit to arrive at the stores perfectly ripe – eliminating the need for store managers to spend time waiting for the green bananas typically found on supermarket shelves to ripen. The downside is profit margins: Chiquita charges C-stores about forty cents per fruit. My 7-Eleven manager can buy bananas at the Trader Joe's down the street for half that. 

Analysis: though it is certainly more profitable for convenience stores to adopt the DIY approach, most local mini-marts probably won't do so – meaning that the Chiquita method will likely be more successful. Whatever else the company does wrong or right, this is a visionary and important (though as-yet unproven) strategy, because it demonstrates the banana's changing – and critical – role in the American diet: as the best, most affordable stand-in for the mountains of junk food that have created a massive juvenile health crisis.
Mobile Blogging from here.
(And about that link in that first paragraph – I'm from Brooklyn.) 

Using the blog…

THE BANANA BLOG is about the world's most endangered - and dangerous - fruit. THE BIG PARADE is about stairways, route and transit geekery, and pedestrian pursuits in Los Angeles. You can also read all the topics at once, which might also include productivity, geekery, DIY whatever, mountain biking, stuff that I think is funny that nobody else likely will, and other boring, useless crap.

Read and Buy Some Books

Nobel Prize winner Paul Krugman recommends it. Listen to my interview on NPR's Fresh Air. My own op-ed in the New York Times.

Other Books:

Visit my bookstore

Connections:

FACEBOOK: dan koeppel / big parade / TWITTER: bigparadela / dan koeppel / RSS: big parade / bananas / asymptotes / everything / CONTACT: email.